What automatically happens if an insured fails to pay the interest on a whole life policy loan when due?

If you carry whole life insurance and have a bank account that’s been hard-hit by the coronavirus pandemic, you might consider borrowing against your policy. Tap your insurance in the wrong way, though, and you could create as many financial problems as you solve.

Unlike a term life policy, which has no value other than what it pays when you die, whole-life insurance has a cash value independent of the death benefit. You can borrow against that value as needed, as I did when I tapped my own policy for $500 decades ago. Given to me as a child by my mother’s father, and with a modest death benefit, the plan was to make sure that I would always have insurance, and to give me an asset that I could borrow against if need be.

Taking a loan from a whole life insurance policy might get you urgently needed money at a favorable interest rate. Handle the loan poorly, however, and you can sabotage your reasons for having the policy in the first place, lose the policy, or create an income tax bill that you can’t afford to pay.

Here’s a rundown of how to raid a whole life policy, along with advice on the wisdom of doing so compared with other potential options.

How whole life insurance works

Unlike term coverage, which protects for a stated period of time—twenty years is typical— whole life insurance stays in effect for as long as the policy is funded.

At the beginning of the policy and for some years, you fund the policy by paying level, annual premiums. Over time, with many policies, you receive dividends based on the insurance company’s financial performance, which you can use to offset premiums. Cash value also accumulates inside your policy, and you can borrow against that cash value.

The case for a loan

Borrowing against a policy’s cash value is a sweet deal in multiple ways. First, the insurance company can’t turn down your application for this loan. If there’s money available to borrow inside your policy, it’s yours to borrow, regardless of your current income or credit report. “They can’t turn you down for a loan unless you’ve already borrowed all the cash value,” says Chapel Hill, North Carolina-based financial planner Michael Whitman.

If you do tap the policy, the insurance company will probably charge you a favorable interest rate. “The better whole life policies have a low rate of interest for borrowing against the cash value,” says Michelle Gessner, a financial advisor in Houston, Texas. “Many of the good life insurance policies are charging less than 5 percent interest. Some policies have a zero cost loan if you've held the policy for ten years or more.”

Ads by Money. We may be compensated if you click this ad.Ad

What automatically happens if an insured fails to pay the interest on a whole life policy loan when due?

A proper life insurance policy will protect your loved ones from the unexpected.

No time like the present to get on the estate planning path. Do it right with life insurance and take care of your family. Click below for more information.

Get a Free Quote

The interest rate you pay to borrow is specified in the policy. What’s more, says Whitman, “the company might even pay the interest into your policy’s cash value.” In other words, you’ll essentially be reimbursed, albeit indirectly, for the cost of borrowing.

Once you’ve taken the loan, there’s no particular repayment schedule. You pay it back if and when you want to. That sounds like a helpful feature, and it can be. Yet it can also turn into a substantial disadvantage.

Repay the principal or reduce your policy benefits

No one will chase you down and insist that you repay the loan from your policy. But if you don’t, you could find yourself with at least one unpleasant surprise.

For one, you could capsize the reason that you bought the policy in the first place. “Whole life policies can grow tax-free, so people use them as retirement supplements,” Gessner says. “If you take a loan when you’re already in retirement, there’s no need to pay it back.” The loan is fulfilling your goal to provide retirement income. “But if you’re not in or close to retirement,” Gessner adds,”you’ll want to pay it back.” Otherwise, the money won’t be there to serve its original purpose.

People also buy whole life policies because their families plan to use the death benefit to care for loved ones or pay estate taxes. You’ll want to fully repay the loan if your heirs need the death benefit. If you die before full repayment, the outstanding balance will be deducted from your death benefit, just like any other loan.

Ignoring interest can collapse the policy

No one will make you pay the interest on your loan, either, and that could become an even bigger problem. “Say you borrow $10,000 from your contract at 5 percent interest,” Whitman says. “Every year, that 5 percent has to be paid back, or the interest will be added to the loan and capitalized.” If you don’t make interest payments, you’ll owe $10,500 by the end of the first year and $11,025 at the end of the second.

The insurance company will credit your dividend against your annual premium, interest, and principal. If the loan is small enough, the dividend might even repay it. That’s what happened with the $500 loan I took out against my policy.

For a bigger loan, though, the dividend will eventually be no match for the power of compound interest. Dividend payments won’t be enough to keep the policy afloat. If you’re not able to pay into the policy, the company will cancel it.

The taxman could cometh

As if cancellation of the policy for non-payment isn't bad enough, you’ll also owe income taxes on the difference between what you paid into the policy and the loan and interest payments you took out. “This is a trap for the unwary,” says New York-based financial advisor David Mendels. “The insurance company is happy to let you treat each unpaid interest payment as effectively a new loan. There’s no tax due until you either decide to or are forced to cancel the policy.”

At that point, all those interest payments and loan principal, minus premiums paid, become taxable as ordinary income. “It’s tough enough to pay taxes on income that you do get,” Mendels says. “It’s really hard to pay taxes on money that you didn’t get.”

You can take a loan and let the policy lapse on purpose, as long as you plan for the tax bill. That’s what Peter Lazaroff, a financial planner in St. Louis, Missouri, did when he bought his first house. He borrowed $30,000 against a whole life policy his parents bought when he was a baby. Three years later, the policy lapsed and Lazaroff paid taxes on about $15,000 — the difference between the premiums paid on the policy and Lazaroff’s loan principal and interest.

If you’re taking a loan because you’re short on funds, you would likely find it difficult to pay extra income tax. But if you know you can pay or offset the taxes — by taking a loss on a different investment, for instance — this strategy might work. Call your insurance company and ask for an in-force illustration to find out how much you can borrow and how long your dividend payments can keep the loan and policy afloat.

Overall, though, you should probably approach borrowing against a whole life policy with caution. “I wouldn’t rule it out, but it wouldn’t be my first choice,” financial advisor Mendels says. “Better choices might include a zero percentage credit card offer, a home equity line of credit, or an emergency fund.” Tapping retirement funds, he says, is a worse choice.

Ads by Money. We may be compensated if you click this ad.Ad

What automatically happens if an insured fails to pay the interest on a whole life policy loan when due?

If your income has taken a hit, a Home Equity Loan may offer less expensive help.

Using a line of credit secured by home equity can aid you in your time of need. Click below to learn more.

GET STARTED

More from Money:

Best Life Insurance Companies of 2020

Life Insurance Rates Are At Historic Lows. But That Probably Won’t Last

Life Insurance For Children: 3 Points Parents Should Keep In Mind

For starters, you have to have the right kind of life insurance policy. There are two main types of life insurance: term life and permanent life. Only permanent policies build cash value. Term life insurance is less expensive, but coverage is temporary, and there's no cash value component, so there's nothing to borrow money against. That's why term life is sometimes called "pure life insurance": it's designed to provide an insurance payout for your beneficiaries if you pass away (the policy's death benefit) but nothing else. 

Permanent life insurance policies are available in two primary forms: whole life insurance and universal life insurance. With these policies, part of your money goes toward a cash value every time you pay a premium, where it builds over time. The rate of cash value growth varies by policy: with whole life, there is typically a set rate of interest, while in some universal policies, cash value growth can be tied to market investments. Either way, the cash value grows tax-deferred - like a retirement account.3 But unlike with IRAs, it can be easy to use the cash value as collateral for a loan.

When can you get a policy loan?

You can take a loan against your policy anytime it has enough value.  It may take several years before the cash value grows into a useful amount.

How do you apply for a policy loan?

The application process tends to be relatively easy, and your insurance agent can help with any issues. Generally speaking, you have to fill out a simple form, either on paper or online, verify your identity, and submit it. Unlike a traditional loan, there's no income or credit check, and your credit score does not affect approval or the interest rate. Because it is fully collateralized by your policy's cash value, the approval process is generally quick, and the loan interest rate is typically lower than a personal loan or even a home equity loan. The money may be deposited into your account within a few days.

Each life insurance company sets its own rules about how much money you can borrow from your policy, but you can typically get a policy loan for up to 90% of the value in your policy. And unlike most loans, there's no set repayment period: you can pay it back in ten months, ten years, or longer -- but if you pass away in that time, any outstanding loan balance will typically be deducted from your death benefit.

Money isn't taken out of your policy

Loan funds don't actually come out of your policy but rather from the company itself who uses your policy as collateral. Since money stays in your policy, it earns interest and grows tax-favored. At the same time, however, you're charged interest on your policy loan. If you don't repay the annual interest, that sum will be added to your loan amount.

What if you decide not to pay back the loan?

You have the option not to repay, but it may not be your best course of action. Interest compounds over time and is added to your loan balance, further lowering your death benefit. And if the total loan balance grows to be larger than your cash value, the policy could lapse. When your policy lapses, the cash you took out may be treated as income, and you could owe taxes on it.

As a rule, life insurance loans can be a more intelligent and accessible option than traditional loans. Qualification is easier compared to a personal loan, and it can be more cost-effective than carrying high-interest credit card debt. However, if you don't want to risk losing your life insurance protection, you have to repay what you borrowed. If you'd rather not pay back a loan, there are other ways to access your policy's cash value (see below).

As long as your cash value is above the minimum required by your insurer for policy loans, approval is essentially automatic with no credit checks or application fees.

Quick access to funds

Cash can be deposited into your account within a few days. You can even use it for stop-gap financing. For example, if you're waiting for approval of another loan but need money immediately, you can quickly take out a policy loan and repay it when the traditional loan comes through.

Lower interest

Since there's essentially no risk to the loan issuer, interest payments and rates are generally lower than when you borrow money with other types of loans.

No set loan repayment schedule

You can use it as a short-term bridge loan while you wait for other financing to come through, or you can take your time and repay over several years.

If you pass away while there's an outstanding loan balance, it will typically be deducted from the full death benefit.

Risk of policy lapse

As long as you just pay interest on the loan amount (along with your normal premiums), this isn't an issue. However, if you make no loan payments at all, the unpaid accumulated interest is added to the loan amount, and you could eventually owe more than the value of your policy. This will cause the policy to lapse.

Borrowing money against cash value is just one of several ways to use this flexible policy asset. Generally speaking, there are three other common ways to access the cash value in a universal or whole life insurance policy:

Cash surrender

One option is to cancel the policy entirely and take the surrender value cash payment, leaving you without life insurance coverage. This option may be considered for people in retirement who need cash to live on and no longer have dependent children. But check the policy contract first: there can be significant surrender fees, especially with a newer policy. Also, if you're thinking about surrendering the policy because you no longer want to pay premiums, consider using the cash value to cover your premium payments instead (see below).

Withdrawal 

In many situations, you can take a cash withdrawal from your permanent life policy, and that money is often not subject to income taxes (as long as it's not more than the premiums you've paid into the policy). However, there are potential disadvantages: your death benefit will likely be reduced, , and that reduction may be greater than the amount withdrawn, depending on the specific terms of your policy. Talk to your agent or life insurance company to find out how withdrawing money from your specific policy works. 

Use the cash value to pay your insurance policy premiums

You can typically use the money in your cash value to pay part or all of your policy premiums, making it much easier to keep your coverage in place. This is a popular option for older policyholders who want to lower their expenses in retirement but still wish to keep life insurance coverage in place. 

Now that you know more about how a universal or whole life insurance policy can be used for borrowing and as a wealth-building asset, you may want to explore what kind of policy is best for your family's needs. Consider talking with a knowledgeable professional who will take the time to learn about your financial situation and goals, then help guide you to the right solution. If you don't have a financial professional to discuss insurance with, Guardian can help you find a nearby financial representative who can help.

Actually, there are several advantages to borrowing against your policy's accumulated cash value, especially when compared to other types of loans. First, the application process is generally easier - you don't have to provide a reason for the loan, and there's no income or credit check. Second, approval tends to happen quickly, and you may have funds deposited in your bank account in just a few days. Third, you may likely pay interest at a lower rate than other loans. Finally, repayment terms are generally flexible: you can take as long as you want to pay the money back.

How much money can I borrow from my life insurance?

This will vary depending on how much cash value you have, the type of policy you own (for example, you can borrow against whole life, but not term life insurance), how long you've had the policy, and the insurance company's rules regarding loans. For example, some policies may not have sufficient value to loan against in the early years. You can typically access up to 90% of the policy’s cash value.

Note that there is a difference between the death benefit – or "face value" – and the cash value of life insurance. Part of each month's premium pays for your life insurance benefit, and part goes to the cash value. The policy's cash value equals part of the premiums paid in, plus any tax-deferred growth.

Do you have to pay back loans on life insurance?

Repayment of a life insurance loan is not required, but it's typically in your interest to do so because the outstanding loan amount detracts from the death benefit. Also, as loan interest compounds over time, the total balance may grow larger than your cash value, causing the policy to lapse. In that event, the cash you took out may be treated as income, and you could owe taxes on it.

Can you cash out a life insurance policy before death?

If you have a permanent life insurance policy, then yes, you can take cash out before your death. In addition to the policy loans described above, you can take out cash value in the form of a withdrawal, either in a lump sum or in payments. As with a policy loan, your death benefit will generally be reduced. The last option is to surrender the policy for cash. Unless you are past retirement age, surrender should be considered a last resort, as this cancels the policy along with your life insurance coverage. With surrender, you may also pay taxes and fees, which can significantly reduce your cash value in a newer policy.

What automatically happens if an insured fails to pay the interest on a whole life policy loan when due?

Get an instant Term Life quote

Go Now